Sherlock's Library

Very negative (22 ratings)

All In Adventures - Columbus [prev. Mystery Room]

Escape room
IRL

Mark as done to rate

The great Sherlock Holmes has gone missing! His stalwart partner, Dr. Watson, suspects that a member of the London aristocracy is to blame. The four aristocrats that recently inquired into the duo's services all share the same accountant... a detail Watson looks to investigate! While Watson works with police to track Holmes down, you have been sent by Sherlock's brother to sniff out any involvement from the accountant. Upon entering the office, you immediately detect a carefully calibrated ruse and find a trail of breadcrumbs left by Sherlock himself! You have a 60 minute window while the accountant is out of office. You’ll have to search his documents, piece together the shady plot, and pinpoint your suspects before he returns to catch you snooping!

2-10
60 mins
Medium
Not scary

Ratings

All ratings (22)

Very negative

Gameplay: Negative

Atmosphere: Negative

Customer service: Mostly positive

Reviews

Hockeydaze

8 escape rooms

If you're walking through the mall with the kids and want to do an escape room, go for it. But for veteran players, this was not a good one. Lots of red herrings, all in one room, you hear all the other escape rooms next to you. It is all opening locks and finding combinations, nothing else mechanical or electric.

Gameplay

Atmosphere

Customer service

Particularly interesting or different

Story

Difficulty

Easy

Game tech

Mechanical

Ideal number of players

Scary

Not scary

Minimum age

Was anything broken?

Live actors

Physically active

Not at all

Easy to find location

Yes

It's in the mall, check the map at the entrance when you get there.

Parking

Easy

Safety

Yes

Mar 12, 2026

CountOrlok

58 escape rooms

I've played worse mall escape rooms, but this was another typical basic single room, typical of what you'd expect from a mall. Lots of reading, not much story and slow paced.