The Return of the Horseman

Instantly book on Morty

The Return of the Horseman

Very positive (14 ratings)

  • Escape room
  • IRL

Mark as done to rate

You’ve been summoned to the Sleepy Hollow Museum—but not as a hero. The town believes you are behind the curse, accused of trying to control the Headless Horseman himself. As the spirits awaken and shadows stir, you must prove your innocence. Find the Horseman’s missing head and return it before midnight… or be claimed by the curse you’re accused of unleashing.

  • 2-10
  • 60 mins
  • Expert
  • Spooky

Ratings

All ratings (14)

Very positive

Gameplay
Very positive
Atmosphere
Very positive
Customer service
Very positive

Reviews

@idoeyes1
idoeyes1

164 escape rooms

Loved this room! Theme was fantastic and the surprises kept coming. Interesting puzzles. We had a lot of fun in this room

  • store/u/b6a81ed7-1dff-4577-a1e6-967bc876ecfa_178.jpg
Gameplay
Atmosphere
Customer service
Particularly interesting or different

Yes

Story
Difficulty

Hard

Ideal number of players

4

Scary

Spooky

Minimum age

13

Was anything broken?

No

Live actors

No

Easy to find location

Yes

Parking

Easy

Nov 23, 2025 | Experienced Nov 23, 2025

g

gcarella

7 escape rooms

We were the first ones to be a test this and the room was absolutely amazing. I know they’ve made a few upgrades since the beta test and honestly I want to go back and do it again. I recommend this to everyone. This is the best escape room I’ve ever done so much attention to detail so well thawed out truly amazing

  • store/u/d2558aed-5f1f-4555-b2d4-ef27d94649e6_63.jpg
Gameplay
Atmosphere
Customer service
Nov 15, 2025
@Virgecat18
Virgecat18

93 escape rooms

This was one of the longest physical rooms we have ever done and it did not disappoint. Well worth a trip for sure.

Gameplay

It flowed very well, you went from one puzzle to the next.

Atmosphere

This was incredible theming, probably one of the best we have ever done. Also I believe one of the longest.

Customer service
Parking

Easy

Nov 9, 2025 | Experienced Nov 9, 2025

j

jackandmom

32 escape rooms

I did this with my mom and in our opinion it is a perfect escape room. We had so much fun, the flow was amazing and the puzzles were all very fun and not overly complex. Scenery was also incredible and honestly we just loved every single part of it. Got out with 12 seconds to spare!

Nov 3, 2025
@LeaIsTrapped
LeaIsTrapped

13 escape rooms

I did this room in their beta testing. It's clear that a lot of thought and work was put into it. Very detailed ambiance and a good diversity of puzzles.

Gameplay
Atmosphere
Customer service
Particularly interesting or different

Yes

Story
Difficulty

Hard

Most of the puzzle are probably medium difficulty, but there are a lot of them.

Game tech

High tech

Ideal number of players

4

Scary

Spooky

Minimum age

10

Was anything broken?

No

Live actors

No

Physically active

Somewhat

A little bit of ducking required. Walking back and forth between rooms.

Accessibility

Completely flat, there is a smaller door that requires ducking. Not sure if it's wide enough for a wheelchair.

Easy to find location

Yes

Parking

Easy

Nov 2, 2025 | Experienced Oct 26, 2025

Showing results 1-5 of 5

Loading...