Magician’s SecretMagician’s SecretMagician’s Secret
1/3

Instantly book on Morty

Magician’s Secret

Very Positive (85 ratings)

  • Escape room
  • IRL

Mark as done to rate

Renowned magician, Howard Thurston, has extended an invitation to your ragtag group to join his traveling magic show. You've cleared the first hurdle, but a more challenging test awaits. Can you work together to find Thurston's hidden journal and secure your place on his team?

  • 2-6
  • 48 mins
  • Medium
  • Not scary

Ratings

All ratings (85)

Very Positive

Gameplay
Very Positive
Atmosphere
Very Positive
Customer service
Very Positive

Reviews

I

InevitablyConsidered

6 escape rooms

Maybe we were just having an off day, or didn't have the right number of people, but this was our least favorite of the ones we did over a Columbus weekend. While the production quality was high and immersive, the puzzles themselves didn't sit well with us.

Gameplay

The puzzles didn't seem consistently fair (e.g. something changing out of sight and nobody was looking at it, or things that were just physically hard to see for older eyes), or had some light brute-forcing explicitly built into it. The pressuring into (very light) roleplay also had a little friction for our introverted group, but another group might really dig it.

Atmosphere

This was overall a highlight. Clearly a ton of work and love has gone into the set design here. The "no hands over this explicit line on the wall" was pretty artificial, though. A couple thematic mechanics were involved that were neat and novel.

Customer service

The GM leaned into the context and atmosphere of the room well, and he also spoon-fed us around some of the rough patches.

Story
Game tech

High tech

Scary

Not scary

Accessibility

Might not be good for lower vision

Easy to find location

No

Safety

Yes

May 24, 2026 | Experienced May 3, 2026

B

BTippett

47 escape rooms

The gameplay was amazing and the puzzles were very unique! The owner of the business was our game master for the room and he did a wonderful job immersing us into the world of the game. He was able to explain the boundaries of the game (such as the off limit areas) in a way that didn’t distract from the world he was building. The mechanics and surrounding props in the escape were in excellent condition. Outside of the provided clues, you didn’t need any outside knowledge to solve the puzzles. This room was a 10/10 for us and we will definitely be visiting their other location when we get the chance!

Gameplay

The gameplay was very unique and it story flowed very well!

Atmosphere

The game master, the props, and the puzzles all aligned with the atmosphere of the escape room to make a very immersive experience!

Customer service

The game master was very welcoming and we had a wonderful chat after the room about any questions or suggestions that we had with the gameplay.

Particularly interesting or different

Yes

The game was very interesting and unique!

Story

The plot was very memorable and all of the puzzles aligned with the plot and story progression!

Difficulty

Hard

As an avid escape room participant, this room gave us a nice challenge without being impossible!

Game tech

High tech

The sensors and lighting in the escape room was amazing visually and worked wonderfully.

Ideal number of players

6

2-6

Scary

Not scary

Was anything broken?

No

Everything was in perfect and working order!

Live actors

Yes

An immersive game master during the introduction to ease you into the world of the escape room.

Physically active

Somewhat

Easy to find location

Yes

Parking

Easy

Safety

Yes

May 13, 2026 | Experienced May 13, 2026

Thank you so much for the incredible 10/10 shout-out on Morty, BTippett! As the owner, it is always a blast hosting players who notice the fine details. I take a lot of pride in crafting a seamless experience right from the start, so hearing that the boundary briefing kept you fully locked into the 1920s world is the ultimate compliment. We work tirelessly to keep our Generation 3 mechanical effects and custom props in pristine condition so the illusion never breaks. We would absolutely love to host you at our sister location, Escape Room Downtown in Canton, when you get the chance! The Bootlegger's Lair features a fantastic, classic design with a completely different style of unique puzzles. It was very much ahead of the time when we created it, and it still holds up very well today. Thanks again for the high praise, and we look forward to seeing you for your next mission! Best, The Magic Escape Rooms Team

May 18, 2026

@maybe04
maybe04

22 escape rooms

We had a blast! I played with my partner and we got to play both of the rooms back to back, we thoroughly enjoyed the stories, set, and really cool puzzles! Our GM helped us with lots of small nudges, and walked us through some puzzles when we were getting really close on time.

Gameplay
Atmosphere
Customer service

Literally best GM ever, such a fun ‘intro’ that is a great break from the typical spiel.

Minimum age

10

Everything is accessible for both adults and children!

May 3, 2026 | Experienced May 2, 2026

Z

ZEB25

12 escape rooms

Highly recommended!

Gameplay
Atmosphere
Customer service
Apr 25, 2026
@NoKeyNoProblem
NoKeyNoProblem

212 escape rooms

Awesome experience starting before entering the room itself. Some puzzles were new and inventive for us as we had not encountered them before. Story throughout felt very immersive. Excited to come back and try their next room.

Gameplay
Atmosphere
Customer service
Particularly interesting or different

No

Story
Difficulty

Medium

Game tech

High tech

Ideal number of players

4

Scary

Spooky

Minimum age

10

Was anything broken?

No

Live actors

No

Physically active

Not at all

Easy to find location

Yes

Parking

Easy

Feb 4, 2026 | Experienced Sep 29, 2025

m

mybelle99

1 escape room

We had such a great time solving the puzzles. The room was well thought out and challenging but not frustrating. We loved the historical aspect as well. Can’t wait to try their other adventure.

Gameplay
Atmosphere
Customer service
Dec 6, 2025 | Experienced Dec 6, 2025
@quietwolfe
quietwolfe

1 escape room

I brought my husband here for his birthday and our experience was outstanding. The puzzles were challenging, but not to the point of frustration. I love that the theme is tied to a historic figure. We look forward to visiting when the next room opens this fall!

Gameplay

Excellent gameplay with a good variety of puzzles and mechanics.

Atmosphere

The host was in character as soon as he greeted us and didn’t break character until we finished. The room theming was great.

Customer service

I have visited a few escape rooms. This was hands down the best GM I’ve encountered.

Particularly interesting or different

Yes

Story
Difficulty

Medium

A few puzzles stumped us for a bit, but feedback from the GM helped.

Game tech

Mechanical

There was a very good blend of tech and mechanics.

Ideal number of players

2

We played as a party of two. There was plenty of space for one or two more, but more than four would have felt crowded. Excellent for couples!

Scary

Not scary

Minimum age

12

An older child would probably enjoy the experience - depends on the child! I would say this is family friendly. Not scary, fun theme.

Was anything broken?

No

Live actors

No

Physically active

Somewhat

Easy to find location

Yes

Parking

Easy

Jul 25, 2025 | Experienced Jul 25, 2025

d

discoballdreamcatcher

59 escape rooms

My husband and I fully loved this game. The passion that the game creator has for escape rooms came through in this room. It’s not unnecessarily hard and the theme is well incorporated. The puzzles are novel and interesting with lots of neat tech and no busy work or scavenger hunt type mechanics. I also appreciate that it didn’t rely on darkness to make things more difficult. Also it’s in a great location. We had a great time.

Gameplay
Atmosphere
Customer service
Particularly interesting or different

Yes

Lots of techy puzzles

Story
Difficulty

Medium

Game tech

High tech

Ideal number of players

2

Scary

Not scary

Minimum age

13

Was anything broken?

No

Live actors

No

Physically active

Not at all

Accessibility

There is one step in the game

Easy to find location

Yes

Parking

Medium

May 17, 2025 | Experienced May 17, 2025
@hopeyffgrbp
hopeyffgrbp

27 escape rooms

First room at this location! Even though it’s more on the mechanically simple side of things, you can really feel the passion put into planning this room. It’s a decent option in the Columbus area, and I look forward to seeing this company expand their options!

  • store/u/0406951d-bc49-4b29-9837-417d2dd30ca8_75.jpg
Gameplay
Atmosphere
Customer service
Particularly interesting or different

No

Story
Difficulty

Medium

Game tech

Mechanical

Ideal number of players

4

Scary

Not scary

Was anything broken?

No

Live actors

No

Physically active

Not at all

Apr 29, 2025 | Experienced Nov 23, 2024

Showing results 1-10 of 25

Loading...