Castaway

While a lot of the work put into theming the room was nice, the puzzles were a bit poorly designed in places, and the flow of events wasn’t always logical. The game master tried to make up for it by giving us excessive hints, often before we had a chance to tackle a puzzle. We only completed the second room out of three, and were a group of 2. It might work better for a larger group.

There were some puzzles in this room that we enjoyed. There were also a lot of logic leaps, a bad flashlight (which our GM did eventually offer to replace, thankfully), and old puzzles that used to be part of the room that aren’t anymore and haven’t been removed. If they did a bit of tweaking, this could be a really good room.

Great room with very challenging puzzles. However, the game master was sluggish when responding when asked for clues (one time we waited over 5 minutes and actually left the room trying to find someone). They also gave us a clue for a puzzle we had already solved.