Tier: B (bordering on C+) (see bio)
I think it’s much more interesting as a piece of Escape Room history (pretty sure it’s 12 years old at this point) than as an actual game. Its horror presentation is only great sometimes and the puzzles feel extremely dated.
(Presentation)
This game, especially its introduction, tries to be really immersive. And that intro succeeds. It gets you into the world really well, though it’s a bit long. Of course, the actor is the highlight. The whole game revolves around them, somewhat to its detriment (see below). There’s also one really great unnerving scene later on that plays into a fear I distinctly remember from elementary school (I have no idea the ethics of it safety-wise though, you’ll see what I mean). But the rest of the game doesn’t do much beyond the general serial killer theme. It’s not even that scary. It’s just relatively ominous with a bit of gore and grossness, with only a couple scares towards the beginning (and those were pretty minor). This makes the game stand out a lot less, but does make it more accessible to people who don’t like horror.
(Gameplay, I guess this paragraph is kind of spoilery)
The gameplay here is pretty bad. There’s a lot of dated things that escape rooms now (or even 5 years ago) would not do. Specifically, there’s a huge emphasis on searching “puzzles” that are impossible to figure out. Only a couple of the puzzles are actually built into the set. All other puzzles are built around small props haphazardly thrown around the room in places that most other games wouldn't even let you check. The only thing making these possible to find is the actor pointing out places to look. This is how the game makes the actor “useful”. But it also makes the game boring as the 2nd half becomes the actor telling you to look somewhere you would never think to look in a million years, you finding something, and then you going back to the actor to ask where another thing is because there’s nothing else to do.
(Overall)
So I really don’t know whether or not I recommend this game. Compared to most-everything else in LA, you really don’t need to play this. But “The Basement” is such a big name in the US Escape Room scene, and there’s still some cool things that I think you should see. If you’re playing everything here (or doing Dead n Breakfast, which I feel is a good deal that lets you finish the games despite the annoyingly short time limits) then do this. And if you really like the serial killer theme also do this. But otherwise, this is my least favorite game here and one of the strangest games in LA.
The Basement Ranking:
1. Courtyard
2. Elevator Shaft
(big jump in quality)
3. Study
4. Basement
Physically active
Somewhat