The way this game starts off is a lot of fun and we had high hopes for it. A few of the puzzles are really good, but so much of it is just bad. More than a few times we questioned why the designers made some of their decisions in this game. There were a few red herrings and things that didn't make sense for that time period. It was all just a mess. It doesn't come close to comparing to their other two rooms. I really feel that with some tweaks in the game design, set design, and some of the puzzles and tasks, this could be a good game. As it stands, I cannot recommend this one.